Canon vs. Fanon, part 10: Pre-series Daniel

Finally, the post so many of you have been nagging me about asking for: Pre-series Daniel!

Backstory is a crucial part of understanding and writing a character. When you consider some of the more iconic fictional characters, nearly all of them reference pivotal moments in the hero's childhood or past to help us understand the driving force behind the character's motivations and actions. Elessar Telcontar, for example, is on a quest to not only redeem his ancestor's mistake, but to prove himself worthy of Arwen in her father's eyes; Clark/Kal-El is the lone survivor of an entire planet, and will do anything in his power to protect his adopted world. (I could go on and on and on in this vein, and thus introduce you all to my favorite books and fandoms, but I think I'd best stop there.) There are very, very few heroes that have made their way into our collective consciousness without giving us at least some glimpse into the backstory.  Sherlock Holmes is one, although we see him through the more immediate filter of Watson's eyes, and we do know Watson's backstory.

How about our heroes from SG-1, then? The details of their backstories are mostly vague, but we do have some basic broad strokes – enough to comprehend their motivations. Jack O'Neill lost his son and was chosen for his suicidal tendencies to be the leader of a suicide mission; Samantha Carter is an Air Force brat who was driven to be better than the best by her need to prove to her father that she was just as good as a son; Teal'c lost his father to the caprices of the Goa'uld and, under Bra'tac's tutelage, determined the falsity of the Goa'uld's claims to divinity and longed to do something about it. (Actually, Teal'c's backstory is probably the most complete of the four.) And Daniel? His motivations are introduced to us from the moment we meet him: brilliant but controversial, Daniel accepted a job when he was practically out on the streets and walked through the Stargate in a driving determination to know that he was right.

So much for the broad strokes. But if we narrow the focus to Daniel, how much do we know about his life before he met Katherine, and how much of the common themes in fanon have any basis in that canon?

( Defining canon for pre-series Daniel )

Unlike most canon vs. fanon discussions, I want to start with the canonical facts and then analyze the common fanon themes to see if they have basis and/or merit. I also will detail exactly when we learn each bit of pre-series history. While I first discovered Stargate in the summer of 2005 and was thus presented with eight years of canon all at once, it's fascinating to consider how slowly real-time fans actually discovered much of Daniel's backstory.

( Canon pre-series Daniel facts )

( Fanon versions of pre-series Daniel )

My personal fanon opinion? The movie and the show have given us very little canon backstory for Daniel – just enough to give us an understanding of his motivations and characterization, and to tantalize us into wanting more. We have a mostly blank canvas on which authors can choose to paint an array of individual and original landscapes… so why, why, why do so many authors choose the easier route of following what so many others have done before – especially when those choices are a direct contradiction to Daniel's personality and character? I appeal to all you wonderful fanfic writers out there: create your own backstory for our archeologist, and make it one that can reasonably allow the delightfully stubborn Dr. Daniel Jackson that we all know and love to come into being!

"Anyway, I'm sorry, but that just happens to be how I feel about it. What do you think?"

Stargate was written by Dean Devin and Roland Emmerich. No copyright infringement is intended by quoting some of its passages in this post.